| National League | American League | ||
| 1957 | No Selection | 1957 | Sherm Lollar (CHI) |
| 1958 | Del Crandall (MIL) | 1958 | Sherm Lollar (CHI) |
| 1959 | Del Crandall (MIL) | 1959 | Sherm Lollar (CHI) |
| 1960 | Del Crandall (MIL) | 1960 | Earl Battey (WAS) |
| 1961 | Johnny Roseboro (LA) | 1961 | Earl Battey (MIN) |
| 1962 | Del Crandall (MIL) | 1962 | Earl Battey (MIN) |
| 1963 | Johnny Edwards (CIN) | 1963 | Elston Howard (NY) |
| 1964 | Johnny Edwards (CIN) | 1964 | Elston Howard (NY) |
| 1965 | Joe Torre (MIL) | 1965 | Bill Freehan (DET) |
| 1966 | Johnny Roseboro (LA) | 1966 | Bill Freehan (DET) |
| 1967 | Randy Hundley (CHI) | 1967 | Bill Freehan (DET) |
| 1968 | Johnny Bench (CIN) | 1968 | Bill Freehan (DET) |
| 1969 | Johnny Bench (CIN) | 1969 | Bill Freehan (DET) |
| 1970 | Johnny Bench (CIN) | 1970 | Ray Fosse (CLE) |
| 1971 | Johnny Bench (CIN) | 1971 | Ray Fosse (CLE) |
| 1972 | Johnny Bench (CIN) | 1972 | Carlton Fisk (BOS) |
| 1973 | Johnny Bench (CIN) | 1973 | Thurman Munson (NY) |
| 1974 | Johnny Bench (CIN) | 1974 | Thurman Munson (NY) |
| 1975 | Johnny Bench (CIN) | 1975 | Thurman Munson (NY) |
| 1976 | Johnny Bench (CIN) | 1976 | Jim Sundberg (TEX) |
| 1977 | Johnny Bench (CIN) | 1977 | Jim Sundberg (TEX) |
| 1978 | Bob Boone (PHI) | 1978 | Jim Sundberg (TEX) |
| 1979 | Bob Boone (PHI) | 1979 | Jim Sundberg (TEX) |
| 1980 | Gary Carter (MON) | 1980 | Jim Sundberg (TEX) |
| 1981 | Gary Carter (MON) | 1981 | Jim Sundberg (TEX) |
| 1982 | Gary Carter (MON) | 1982 | Bob Boone (CAL) |
| 1983 | Tony Pena (PIT) | 1983 | Lance Parrish (DET) |
| 1984 | Tony Pena (PIT) | 1984 | Lance Parrish (DET) |
| 1985 | Tony Pena (PIT) | 1985 | Lance Parrish (DET) |
| 1986 | Jody Davis (CHI) | 1986 | Bob Boone (CAL) |
| 1987 | Mike LaValliere (PIT) | 1987 | Bob Boone (CAL) |
| 1988 | Benito Santiago (SD) | 1988 | Bob Boone (CAL) |
| 1989 | Benito Santiago (SD) | 1989 | Bob Boone (CAL) |
| 1990 | Benito Santiago (SD) | 1990 | Sandy Alomar Jr. (CLE) |
| 1991 | Tom Pagnozzi (STL) | 1991 | Tony Pena (BOS) |
| 1992 | Tom Pagnozzi (STL) | 1992 | Ivan Rodriguez (TEX) |
| 1993 | Kirt Manwaring (SF) | 1993 | Ivan Rodriguez (TEX) |
| 1994 | Tom Pagnozzi (STL) | 1994 | Ivan Rodriguez (TEX) |
| 1995 | Charles Johnson (FLA) | 1995 | Ivan Rodriguez (TEX) |
| 1996 | Charles Johnson (FLA) | 1996 | Ivan Rodriguez (TEX) |
| 1997 | Charles Johnson (FLA) | 1997 | Ivan Rodriguez (TEX) |
| 1998 | Charles Johnson (LA) | 1998 | Ivan Rodriguez (TEX) |
| 1999 | Mike Lieberthal (PHI) | 1999 | Ivan Rodriguez (TEX) |
| 2000 | Mike Matheny (STL) | 2000 | Ivan Rodriguez (TEX) |
| 2001 | Brad Ausmus (HOU) | 2001 | Ivan Rodriguez (TEX) |
| 2002 | Brad Ausmus (HOU) | 2002 | Bengie Molina (ANA) |